Thread "The oath of rating" in forum "Comic Talk and General Discussion *"

Posted at 10:09AM, Sep. 15, 2006

I, Antony Quang, swear on the non-tangible internet that I will try my best to rate what a comic page truely deserves, regardless of the author is a friend or foe.

I hearby heed to use the five point system as what it was meant for, and not as to just give fives.

I shall promise to keep to the following marking for all future comments

1: Really bad. No effort given.
2: Readable, still needs a lot of effort.
3: Acceptable, nothing bad or good about it.
4: Well done, still a few concerns needed to be sorted out.
5: Lots of effort, entertaining, shows author's willingness.

If I do not hold to these promises, may pianos fall on my head.

You can join in too if you want to.

Posted at 11:09AM, Sep. 15, 2006

I, Terminal, promise to leave no rating and surrealistic posts on comics.

.: Myxomatosis :.

Posted at 11:09AM, Sep. 15, 2006

Alright, I don't usually use ratings, but I'll swear that if I do it'll be honest.

Posted at 9:09PM, Sep. 15, 2006

I, Rich/Equinox swear that I shall use the powers of 'HONEST CRITIQUING' for the good of mankind.

Me too, cept I may use a lil evil too… nah… good is fine with me.

Posted at 11:09PM, Sep. 15, 2006

5 everything I like.

4 non sprite comics that really need to do something about their work.

and that's that.

Posted at 7:09AM, Sep. 16, 2006

I never use the rating system anymore.

Except on SA. Because it will live…

Posted at 8:09AM, Sep. 16, 2006

I, Mimarin, master of the three spoons of galrakion, bearer of the standard of the great turtle, promise to hearby rate however I damn well please.

Posted at 12:09PM, Sep. 16, 2006

I Titch, swear I will try to give as many 1's as possible with as little justification as I can get away with.

Posted at 12:09PM, Sep. 16, 2006

I do so swear, as standard-bearer and liege of SoS and HSVoD, that I shall rate comic pages depending on how much I like them, not merely because the person is my friend.

Posted at 12:09PM, Sep. 16, 2006

I The Mediocre one promise to PIMP SLAP those who deserve/need it with the power of numbers.

Posted at 12:09PM, Sep. 16, 2006

I The Mediocre one promise to PIMP SLAP those who deserve/need it with the power of numbers.

actually, I want to change mine to that.

Posted at 2:09PM, Sep. 26, 2006

I, Alex Curtin, from today foward will rate comics in a sensible and concrete manner - giving fives to every comic that I click on.

Don't worry, I'm not being serious.

Posted at 2:09PM, Sep. 26, 2006

I, hat, thinks that this topic is silly.