Thread "Who wants a free review of their comic?" in forum "Networking & Community Projects*"

Posted at 8:07PM, Jul. 2, 2010

No problem usedbooks and CuttingRoom, I'll add.. er… Used Books.. and… The Cutting Room…

DrLuck, we can't add Loonatic's Tale until we've reviewed Crossbones. But once we do, remind one of us and we'll put it on for you.

A reminder - all comics that have been placed on hold, we will permanently drop from our list unless the authors contact us within two weeks (with the exception of No Talent, whose postponement was just recently requested).

Now, the updated list:

Mob Ties (this week)
Anecdote
@$$hole!
Revfitz
Anatta
Agency
Salt the Holly
Hyacinth Duck
Razor Candy
Stitches
Opaque Dreams
Light Within Shadow
Trolling Around
Gothenreich Chronicles
Eternal Flame
Billy Learns to Rock
Last Place Comics
Chronicles of Wyrden
Orbit
Weave
Coming Soon
That's Comical
Achievement Wh0rz
Fate of the Blue Star
Something to Do
Jundooz
The Misadventures of SuperMilo
Misfire Reactional
Crossbones
Wrong Turn Comics
Art Captions
Nectar of the Gods
Deep Hurting
Alwin of the Bots
Real-Super
Devil Grass
Acting Out
Adam and Darcys Shenanigans
Malefic
Kids with Gas Eat Free
Pink Lady
Punk-Punk!
Pep Squad
Silent Hill Too
Seedy Comics
RPS
Used Books
Starsearchers
The Cutting Room

-On hold until further notice-
Out There
Eternal Illusion
Timeloss
Sentinel
Hainted Holler
South of Sanity
Jake the Evil Hare
No Talent

Posted at 8:07PM, Jul. 10, 2010

Just a couple of quick questions.

One: If we have thirty comics uploaded, but not live, can we sign up for the list?

Two: Do you read the author's comments as well?

Three: If the answer to one is yes, will you please put Doodles of a Mental Person down for a review?

thanks that is all.

Posted at 3:07PM, Jul. 11, 2010

Ehh… we'd rather not, Salsa. It's too much to keep track of, and it's easier if the pages are all uploaded. And yes, we do read the author's comments.

And our updated list:

Anecdote
@$$hole!
Revfitz
Anatta
Agency
Salt the Holly
Hyacinth Duck
Razor Candy
Stitches
Opaque Dreams
Light Within Shadow
Trolling Around
Gothenreich Chronicles
Eternal Flame
Billy Learns to Rock
Last Place Comics
Chronicles of Wyrden
Orbit
Weave
Coming Soon
That's Comical
Achievement Wh0rz
Fate of the Blue Star
Something to Do
Jundooz
The Misadventures of SuperMilo
Misfire Reactional
Crossbones
Wrong Turn Comics
Art Captions
Nectar of the Gods
Deep Hurting
Alwin of the Bots
Real-Super
Devil Grass
Acting Out
Adam and Darcys Shenanigans
Malefic
Kids with Gas Eat Free
Pink Lady
Punk-Punk!
Pep Squad
Silent Hill Too
Seedy Comics
RPS
Used Books
Starsearchers
The Cutting Room
The Garden

The authors of the following comics have until this Friday to contact us if they want to secure their place on the list - otherwise we'll be dropping them entirely:

Out There
Eternal Illusion
Timeloss
Sentinel
Hainted Holler
South of Sanity
Jake the Evil Hare
No Talent

Posted at 4:07PM, Jul. 11, 2010

That's ok, I'll just wait until then.

Posted at 6:07PM, Jul. 13, 2010

I better give this a bump back to the top if we have competition now.

Posted at 10:07PM, Jul. 13, 2010

Updated List:

Anecdote (This week)
@$$hole!
Revfitz
No Talent
Anatta
Eternal Illusion
Agency
Salt the Holly
Hyacinth Duck
Razor Candy
Stitches
Opaque Dreams
Light Within Shadow
Trolling Around
Gothenreich Chronicles
Eternal Flame
Billy Learns to Rock
Last Place Comics
Chronicles of Wyrden
Orbit
Weave
Coming Soon
That's Comical
Achievement Wh0rz
Fate of the Blue Star
Something to Do
Jundooz
The Misadventures of SuperMilo
Misfire Reactional
Crossbones
Wrong Turn Comics
Art Captions
Nectar of the Gods
Deep Hurting
Alwin of the Bots
Real-Super
Devil Grass
Acting Out
Adam and Darcys Shenanigans
Malefic
Kids with Gas Eat Free
Pink Lady
Punk-Punk!
Pep Squad
Silent Hill Too
Seedy Comics
RPS
Used Books
Starsearchers
The Cutting Room
The Garden

Posted at 2:07AM, Jul. 16, 2010

Alright, yet another list update, and the on-hold list is officially gone.

It's gone... just gone.

@$$hole!
Revfitz
No Talent
Anatta
Eternal Illusion
Agency
Salt the Holly
Hyacinth Duck
Razor Candy
Stitches
Opaque Dreams
Light Within Shadow
Trolling Around
Gothenreich Chronicles
Eternal Flame
Billy Learns to Rock
Last Place Comics
Chronicles of Wyrden
Orbit
Weave
Coming Soon
That's Comical
Achievement Wh0rz
Fate of the Blue Star
Something to Do
Jundooz
The Misadventures of SuperMilo
Misfire Reactional
Crossbones
Wrong Turn Comics
Art Captions
Nectar of the Gods
Deep Hurting
Alwin of the Bots
Real-Super
Devil Grass
Acting Out
Adam and Darcys Shenanigans
Malefic
Kids with Gas Eat Free
Pink Lady
Punk-Punk!
Pep Squad
Silent Hill Too
Seedy Comics
RPS
Used Books
Starsearchers
The Cutting Room
The Garden
The Portland Express
Daryl and Susie

Posted at 9:07AM, Jul. 18, 2010

I got 30 pages now
:O
http://www.drunkduck.com/The_Discovery_of_Mafital/index.php

Posted at 6:07PM, Jul. 18, 2010

Well… I guess I'll throw Kimeral in the line as well, lol. I'm a little worried since it seems like you guys are pretty harsh, but I'd like to get some honest feedback.

http://www.drunkduck.com/Kimeral/

Posted at 4:07PM, Jul. 19, 2010

Those brave souls who ask are rewarded!

@$$hole!
Revfitz
No Talent
Anatta
Eternal Illusion
Agency
Salt the Holly
Hyacinth Duck
Razor Candy
Stitches
Opaque Dreams
Light Within Shadow
Trolling Around
Gothenreich Chronicles
Eternal Flame
Billy Learns to Rock
Last Place Comics
Chronicles of Wyrden
Orbit
Weave
Coming Soon
That's Comical
Achievement Wh0rz
Fate of the Blue Star
Something to Do
Jundooz
The Misadventures of SuperMilo
Misfire Reactional
Crossbones
Wrong Turn Comics
Art Captions
Nectar of the Gods
Deep Hurting
Alwin of the Bots
Real-Super
Devil Grass
Acting Out
Adam and Darcys Shenanigans
Malefic
Kids with Gas Eat Free
Pink Lady
Punk-Punk!
Pep Squad
Silent Hill Too
Seedy Comics
RPS
Used Books
Starsearchers
The Cutting Room
The Garden
The Portland Express
Daryl and Susie
The Discovery or Mafital
Kimeral

Posted at 1:07AM, Jul. 20, 2010

Well, since you guys put your comics on our chopping block, I might as well put mine on yours. Add Doodles of a Mental Person please.

Posted at 9:07PM, Jul. 22, 2010

Yoo gawt it, meester.

Revfitz (or Mr. Square) <—-this week
No Talent
Plural Bonerage
Anatta
Eternal Illusion
Agency
Salt the Holly
Hyacinth Duck
Razor Candy
Stitches
Opaque Dreams
Light Within Shadow
Trolling Around
Gothenreich Chronicles
Eternal Flame
Billy Learns to Rock
Last Place Comics
Chronicles of Wyrden
Orbit
Weave
Coming Soon
That's Comical
Achievement Wh0rz
Fate of the Blue Star
Something to Do
Jundooz
The Misadventures of SuperMilo
Misfire Reactional
Crossbones
Wrong Turn Comics
Art Captions
Nectar of the Gods
Deep Hurting
Alwin of the Bots
Real-Super
Devil Grass
Acting Out
Adam and Darcys Shenanigans
Malefic
Kids with Gas Eat Free
Pink Lady
Punk-Punk!
Pep Squad
Silent Hill Too
Seedy Comics
RPS
Used Books
Starsearchers
The Cutting Room
The Garden
The Portland Express
Daryl and Susie
The Discovery or Mafital
Kimeral
Doodles of a Mental Person

Posted at 10:07AM, Jul. 26, 2010

Don't know if I'm the only or first to come back for another hit to the gonads but I'll sign I am up to this.

Get ready for more red eyed, insulting, amazing action!

Posted at 7:07PM, Jul. 29, 2010

I AM I AM I AM

…sorry, that made me want to sing STP. Alright, you're added!

Current list:

No Talent (this week)
Plural Bonerage
Anatta
Eternal Illusion
Agency
Salt the Holly
Hyacinth Duck
Razor Candy
Stitches
Opaque Dreams
Light Within Shadow
Trolling Around
Gothenreich Chronicles
Eternal Flame
Billy Learns to Rock
Last Place Comics
Chronicles of Wyrden
Orbit
Weave
Coming Soon
That's Comical
Achievement Wh0rz
Fate of the Blue Star
Something to Do
Jundooz
The Misadventures of SuperMilo
Misfire Reactional
Crossbones
Wrong Turn Comics
Art Captions
Nectar of the Gods
Deep Hurting
Alwin of the Bots
Real-Super
Devil Grass
Acting Out
Adam and Darcys Shenanigans
Malefic
Kids with Gas Eat Free
Pink Lady
Punk-Punk!
Pep Squad
Silent Hill Too
Seedy Comics
RPS
Used Books
Starsearchers
The Cutting Room
The Garden
The Portland Express
Daryl and Susie
The Discovery or Mafital
Kimeral
Doodles of a Mental Person
I Am

Posted at 9:07AM, Jul. 30, 2010

Well, Please add Randi
If ya 'all's doin one review a week it'll be a year before Randi is reviewed.
Is this correct?

Posted at 4:07PM, Jul. 30, 2010

I'm afraid so, tiki. But at least it'll be before we all die in 2012.

Wow, that would be a crappy last thought.. "I'LL NEVER GET MY REVIEW"

Current list:

No Talent (this week)
Plural Bonerage
Jake the Evil Hare
Anatta
Eternal Illusion
Agency
Salt the Holly
Hyacinth Duck
Razor Candy
Stitches
Opaque Dreams
Light Within Shadow
Trolling Around
Gothenreich Chronicles
Eternal Flame
Billy Learns to Rock
Last Place Comics
Chronicles of Wyrden
Orbit
Weave
Coming Soon
That's Comical
Achievement Wh0rz
Fate of the Blue Star
Something to Do
Jundooz
The Misadventures of SuperMilo
Misfire Reactional
Crossbones
Wrong Turn Comics
Art Captions
Nectar of the Gods
Deep Hurting
Alwin of the Bots
Real-Super
Devil Grass
Acting Out
Adam and Darcys Shenanigans
Malefic
Kids with Gas Eat Free
Pink Lady
Punk-Punk!
Pep Squad
Silent Hill Too
Seedy Comics
RPS
Used Books
Starsearchers
The Cutting Room
The Garden
The Portland Express
Daryl and Susie
The Discovery or Mafital
Kimeral
Doodles of a Mental Person
I Am
Randi

Posted at 1:08PM, Aug. 2, 2010

Holy fuck we got featured.

Current list:

No Talent (this week)
Plural Bonerage
Jake the Evil Hare
Anatta
Eternal Illusion
Agency
Salt the Holly
Hyacinth Duck
Razor Candy
Opaque Dreams
Light Within Shadow
Trolling Around
Gothenreich Chronicles
Eternal Flame
Billy Learns to Rock
Last Place Comics
Chronicles of Wyrden
Orbit
Weave
Coming Soon
That's Comical
Achievement Wh0rz
Fate of the Blue Star
Something to Do
Jundooz
The Misadventures of SuperMilo
Misfire Reactional
Crossbones
Wrong Turn Comics
Art Captions
Nectar of the Gods
Deep Hurting
Alwin of the Bots
Real-Super
Devil Grass
Acting Out
Adam and Darcys Shenanigans
Malefic
Kids with Gas Eat Free
Pink Lady
Punk-Punk!
Pep Squad
Silent Hill Too
Seedy Comics
RPS
Used Books
Starsearchers
The Cutting Room
The Garden
The Portland Express
Daryl and Susie
The Discovery or Mafital
Kimeral
Doodles of a Mental Person
I Am
Randi
Faust
Choose Your Own Nedventure
The Rose Killer
Soul Symphony
Aeria

Posted at 6:08PM, Aug. 3, 2010

Meh, why not? I shamelessly throw my comic to your mix. At least when the time comes 'round, it will have at least become less boring than it is now (hopefully).

Posted at 7:08AM, Aug. 4, 2010

Could you guys review Quest For Zanvadas? It has over 30 pages, if you count the chapter covers :)

Posted at 6:08PM, Aug. 10, 2010

No problem guys, you're both on. Always a pleasure reviewing your stuff, Hunch… wow, it's going to be three comics from one person now!

Er… once another thirteen or fourteen months passes, at least…

Jake the Evil Hare (this Friday)
Anatta
Eternal Illusion
Agency
Salt the Holly
Hyacinth Duck
Razor Candy
Opaque Dreams
Light Within Shadow
Trolling Around
Gothenreich Chronicles
Eternal Flame
Billy Learns to Rock
Last Place Comics
Chronicles of Wyrden
Orbit
Weave
Coming Soon
That's Comical
Achievement Wh0rz
Fate of the Blue Star
Something to Do
Jundooz
The Misadventures of SuperMilo
Misfire Reactional
Crossbones
Wrong Turn Comics
Art Captions
Nectar of the Gods
Deep Hurting
Alwin of the Bots
Real-Super
Devil Grass
Acting Out
Adam and Darcys Shenanigans
Malefic
Kids with Gas Eat Free
Pink Lady
Punk-Punk!
Pep Squad
Silent Hill Too
Seedy Comics
RPS
Used Books
Starsearchers
The Cutting Room
The Garden
The Portland Express
Daryl and Susie
The Discovery or Mafital
Kimeral
Doodles of a Mental Person
I Am
Randi
Faust
Choose Your Own Nedventure
The Rose Killer
Soul Symphony
Aeria
Doug N Exile
Quest for Zanvadas

Posted at 8:08AM, Aug. 13, 2010

Please take Randi off the list.

If anyone cares why:
http://www.drunkduck.com/community/view_topic.php?tid=54237&cid=225

Posted at 5:08PM, Aug. 18, 2010

Aw I'm sorry to hear that, Randi. Hopefully that will resolve itself sooner than later.

Alright, current list:

Anatta (This week)
Agency
Salt the Holly
Hyacinth Duck
Razor Candy
Opaque Dreams
Light Within Shadow
Trolling Around
Gothenreich Chronicles
Eternal Flame
Billy Learns to Rock
Last Place Comics
Chronicles of Wyrden
Orbit
Weave
Coming Soon
That's Comical
Achievement Wh0rz
Fate of the Blue Star
Something to Do
Jundooz
The Misadventures of SuperMilo
Misfire Reactional
Crossbones
Wrong Turn Comics
Art Captions
Nectar of the Gods
Deep Hurting
Alwin of the Bots
Real-Super
Devil Grass
Acting Out
Adam and Darcys Shenanigans
Malefic
Kids with Gas Eat Free
Pink Lady
Punk-Punk!
Pep Squad
Silent Hill Too
Seedy Comics
RPS
Used Books
Starsearchers
The Cutting Room
The Garden
The Portland Express
Daryl and Susie
The Discovery or Mafital
Kimeral
Doodles of a Mental Person
I Am
Faust
Choose Your Own Nedventure
The Rose Killer
Soul Symphony
Aeria
Doug N Exile
Quest for Zanvadas

Posted at 6:08PM, Aug. 18, 2010

Can you take Doodles off the list. I honestly don't know if I'm gonna update it regularly again. I'm thinking about doing a few short stories. Would you make an exception for a comic that's under 30 pages if it's complete?

Posted at 10:08PM, Aug. 18, 2010

I don't see anything wrong with that; the main reason we made that rule was to make sure that newer comics would have a decent amount of their respective plots for us to look over. If someone feels they can tell a convincing story and wrap it up in less than thirty pages, then that should be alright. I'll see what Hark thinks, but it's perfectly fine by me.

EDIT: Whoops forgot to take Doodles off the list

Anatta (This week)
Agency
Salt the Holly
Hyacinth Duck
Razor Candy
Opaque Dreams
Light Within Shadow
Trolling Around
Gothenreich Chronicles
Eternal Flame
Billy Learns to Rock
Last Place Comics
Chronicles of Wyrden
Orbit
Weave
Coming Soon
That's Comical
Achievement Wh0rz
Fate of the Blue Star
Something to Do
Jundooz
The Misadventures of SuperMilo
Misfire Reactional
Crossbones
Wrong Turn Comics
Art Captions
Nectar of the Gods
Deep Hurting
Alwin of the Bots
Real-Super
Devil Grass
Acting Out
Adam and Darcys Shenanigans
Malefic
Kids with Gas Eat Free
Pink Lady
Punk-Punk!
Pep Squad
Silent Hill Too
Seedy Comics
RPS
Used Books
Starsearchers
The Cutting Room
The Garden
The Portland Express
Daryl and Susie
The Discovery or Mafital
Kimeral
I Am
Faust
Choose Your Own Nedventure
The Rose Killer
Soul Symphony
Aeria
Doug N Exile
Quest for Zanvadas

Posted at 6:08PM, Aug. 23, 2010

List update!

Agency (This week)
Salt the Holly
Hyacinth Duck
Razor Candy
Opaque Dreams
Light Within Shadow
Trolling Around
Gothenreich Chronicles
Eternal Flame
Billy Learns to Rock
Last Place Comics
Chronicles of Wyrden
Orbit
Weave
Coming Soon
That's Comical
Achievement Wh0rz
Fate of the Blue Star
Something to Do
Jundooz
The Misadventures of SuperMilo
Misfire Reactional
Crossbones
Wrong Turn Comics
Art Captions
Nectar of the Gods
Deep Hurting
Alwin of the Bots
Real-Super
Devil Grass
Acting Out
Adam and Darcys Shenanigans
Malefic
Kids with Gas Eat Free
Pink Lady
Punk-Punk!
Pep Squad
Silent Hill Too
Seedy Comics
RPS
Used Books
Starsearchers
The Cutting Room
The Garden
The Portland Express
Daryl and Susie
The Discovery or Mafital
Kimeral
I Am
Faust
Choose Your Own Nedventure
The Rose Killer
Soul Symphony
Aeria
Doug N Exile
Quest for Zanvadas
Perpendicular Universe
Birds of a Feather
If It Wasn't for Those Damn Whelks
Lego Space
1337 Joe and Fellow Seth
DNC DNC Revolution