Waff has there ever been a time, in the history of DD mafia, where I have not been a top suspect?
Niccea okay that argument makes more sense.
I suppose we can bide our time a little…..
Start publishing on
DD Comics!
Advertise with us
MAFIA... and other forum games
Mafia II: The Expanded Edition
I LIKE TO LICK YOU!Niccea you have not really disproved my logic.
Your counter argument seems to amount to "no it isn't, you are a sore loser"
I am basing what I am saying on a logical idea.
The masons would all vote for one of the masons to be mayor (unless that are idiots) since they know each other to innocent, so would desperately want one of their own as mayor to avoid a mafia mayor.
The mafia are obviously going to be desperate for a mafia mayor, so clearly one of the main candidates has to be mafia (unless you are claiming the mafia just are not trying very hard and did not bother to try and get that role).
My plan is execute you, if you are not mafia we execute ochi, and if you are both innocent, I screwed up you will probably all execute me for being having set you up (I haven't set you up and I believe what I am saying is correct, but there is a possibility I am wrong, so I am accepting the reality of the situation.)
Since I am putting my own neck on the line if I am wrong, I hardly think you can put this down to me being a "sore loser". If I have misread the situation, the consequences for me are obvious. I am ready to put my life on the line to defeat the mafia. I am not asking any more from you and ochi. One of you is very likely to be a bad guy, and so we have to start by killing one of you.
What I'm seeing a lot of here is "Lets kill them both, including the current mayor for minimal factual reasoning." You're jumping the gun and being over dramatic about it…AGAIN. Look what happened the last time the town didn't wait to receive clue before deciding who to lynch, you lynched the bloody detective. Yes, the first lynch has the greatest chance for hitting a townie, but if you don't wait for some bloody clues to make up your mind, you almost certain to lynch a townie. Why? For the exact same reason you believe that the town simply outnumbers the mafia.
Now I can just see it running through your thick skull now "OMG HE DOESN'T WANT NICCEA OR OCHI LYNCHED! HE MUST BE MAFIA!" Just because I am calling for a little thing like patience doesn't mean I'm mafia, it means I'm playing with my brain. We take the clues from the night's action and then look at events during the vote. The more patient and thoughtful we are about things, the greater our chances are of hitting a mafia member.
No, my list is about 8 people.
All the people who supported Niccea and Ochi.
Who did you vote for again Dukat?
Also everyone seems to keep over looking that the mafia has a member that can kill poeple and leave no clues. Do people understand that?
There is no guarantee of any clues in this game.
I think my reasoning that one of the candidates and their supporters is likely a mafia is pretty good. I am certain one of them is mafia. If niether of them are the mafia is so ineffectual that we will almsot certainly beat them anyway.
Ah but niccea I already.
If you and ochi are innocent I fully anticipate I will be the next to die (I've explained this a few times now, I am starting to feel redundant.)
I am innocent, but if my theory is in correct, I am the next logical one to lynch.
I have to be honest, I dont really know how many more ways I can explain that.
Warning to all mafia: submit a name for your organization to humorman by 11 PM PST or I will give you your own name and you won't like it.I personally like "The smelly bastards"
I'm sure the mafia will agree. D:<
Also everyone seems to keep over looking that the mafia has a member that can kill poeple and leave no clues.Not particulally. If they were to act super suspicious, we would pick up on it.
Also, the detective might find them, although I don't quite understand the detective's powers. :|
niccea the sooner we lynch someone the sooner we can kill mafias.
Yes we are more likely to kill some townies early on, but if we lose the odd member it makes little difference to our ability to attack the mafia.
if the mafia lose people it massively weakens their ability to retaliate.
Also, we are no Pavlov's dogs, waiting around to be fed clues, we can take the inniative. We can soak up casualties far better then the enemy can, we need to take advantage of that.
Niccea you and ochi are supicious by virtue of your success.
Look at the last game, skoolmunkee ran for mayor and then became pardoner when she could not get mayor. The mafia WILL have put someone up to be mayor and that candidate will have got a lot of votes.
Ochi has an especially rapid rise to power, and her supporters seem very defensive of their beloved leader. That strikes me as odd considering they supposedly have no way of knowing if she is good or bad.
And for the last time….
THE ASSASSIN IN THE MAFIA DOES NOT LEAVE CLUES!
Unless the mafia are brain dead they will have the assassin do all the killing and we will get no clues! Am I the only one that can read what the assassin does?
so we have to wait till they target the mayor (who they will obviously leave for last), the paranoid or the veteran?
That is even worse odds then just random lynchings!
Lynching people we get a 5 out of 20 or 1 in 4 chance.
waiting for the mafia to hit the wrong person is only (roughly) a 2 out of 19 chance (assuming they don't go for the mayor)
And that just means we will gets clue, not a dead mafia.
All the people who supported Niccea and Ochi.
I think my reasoning that one of the candidates and their supporters is likely a mafia is pretty good. I am certain one of them is mafia. If niether of them are the mafia is so ineffectual that we will almsot certainly beat them anyway.
Harkovast, you were one of the top candidates. There's no reason why your voters, OR you, are ANY less suspicious. You say we're both suspicious because we were successful - SO WERE YOU. You were tied with her, and I only won by one vote! It wasn't a two-person race, like you're describing it, so even the way you're depicting this is a lie!
You could easily be trying to draw suspicion to us just so that it won't be with YOU, Harkovast. I don't trust your reasoning at all if it's going to exclude you, and this is making you look more suspicious to me every time you try to argue it!
Crotcy I am not sure if you are deliberately lying or ill informed.
Skoolmunkee ran for mayor in the last game. She then ran for pardoner (and won!)
If we had lynched ozone and skool munkee in the last game right at the start we would have eliminated a townie and a mafia, which from our point of view is a win because we out number them 3 to 1.
Ochit I never denied I was suspicious for doing so well. Why do I feel like I am living on planet ground hog day? I am repeating the same arguments again and again because no one seems to be listening.
I already explained that if you two are innocent, I would be the next logical choice (I am innocent, but I realise that if my theory on you two is wrong I will look very guilty).
Seriously, I cant keep typing this out again and again and again!
The top suspects logically should be-
Ochi
Niccea
then Me.
I know I am innocent, so naturally I believe one of the other two is mafia.
Do I need a flow chart for this?
Advertise with us
DDComics is community owned.
The following patrons help keep the lights on. You can support DDComics on Patreon.
- Banes
- JustNoPoint
- RMccool
- Abt_Nihil
- Gunwallace
- cresc
- PaulEberhardt
- Emma_Clare
- FunctionCreep
- SinJinsoku
- Smkinoshita
- jerrie
- Chickfighter
- Andreas_Helixfinger
- Tantz_Aerine
- Genejoke
- Davey Do
- Gullas
- Roma
- NanoCritters
- Teh Andeh
- Peipei
- Digital_Genesis
- Hushicho
- Palouka
- Cheeko
- Paneltastic
- L.C.Stein
- Zombienomicon
- Dpat57
- Bravo1102
- TheJagged
- LoliGen
- OrcGirl
- Fallopiancrusader
- Arborcides
- ChipperChartreuse
- Mogtrost
- InkyMoondrop
- jgib99
- Call me tom
- OrGiveMeDeath_Ind
- Mks_monsters
- GregJ
- HawkandFloAdventures
- Soushiyo