Thread "Who wants a free review of their comic?" in forum "Networking & Community Projects*"

Posted at 3:08PM, Aug. 10, 2009

Just checked out the first page you guys made. It looks like you give a fairly decent review, mentioning the good and the bad stuff of the comic.

I myself have a comic that's conveniently at the 30 page mark but since I'm restarting it, I guess I'm gonna wait until I build up the page numbers of the new project.

Posted at 10:08PM, Aug. 10, 2009

Niccea, I just want to make sure; are you volunteering Mystery Bread for a review?

Yah.

Posted at 10:08AM, Aug. 11, 2009

Wow, this is really generating some enthusiasm.
You are all brave souls, and salute you!

Posted at 6:08AM, Aug. 12, 2009

I hate to tell you this, but somebody is running an almost identical project in the Hey Everyone Look What I Did section.

Posted at 8:08AM, Aug. 12, 2009

I hate to tell you this, but somebody is running an almost identical project in the Hey Everyone Look What I Did section.

Zomg! He's right!

Not only is somebody ripping off your idea Hark, his name is also Harkovast.

You need to take down this impostor and take him down hard!

Posted at 9:08AM, Aug. 12, 2009

Not only is somebody ripping off your idea Hark, his name is also Harkovast.

You need to take down this impostor and take him down hard!

Wait - how do we know that guy isn't the real Harkovast and this guy is the imposter?

Posted at 5:08PM, Aug. 18, 2009

hey guys, let me hop onto the bandwagon too. Whenever you get around to it I'd be much obliged.

Posted at 5:08AM, Aug. 20, 2009

When I first read about this comic in the news - specifically the part about it being a community project - I thought maybe you'd accept guest reviews? I'd actually be more interested in that than having one of my comics reviewed (reviewing signifikat might make sense if you're interested in talky, whiny comics though - I just don't want to read in your review that it's talky or whiny).

(BTW, this is the explanation for my "give me time" comment on the 2nd page, which otherwise might seem weird - at that point I simply hadn't realized the only way to contribute would be submitting a comic. Sorry for being slow.)

Posted at 5:08AM, Aug. 20, 2009

I would very much like my Stuff to be reviewed as any publicity is good publicity. Even if it's an inevitably bad review :)

Posted at 6:08AM, Aug. 20, 2009

I'd love to have "Good Guy" reviewed.

Posted at 6:08AM, Aug. 20, 2009

I would like mine reviewed just for lulz.

Posted at 1:08PM, Aug. 20, 2009

I've always wanted to be chewed up and spat out! Really though, after 350+ pages, I'd like to know what's working with my story and what isn't. I feel like I can definitely improve, but I don't know WHERE, per say. Triple Torture.

Posted at 6:08PM, Aug. 20, 2009

Ooh, ooh, pick me! Stickman and Cube could use some reviewing.

Posted at 4:08AM, Aug. 22, 2009

Oh man, you offer webcomic people some free publicity…you might as well throw blood in a shark tank!

I say we only review comics with EXACTLY 30 pages! That would make people work for it a bit!

Well, The Symmetrical Breadpazoid will have exactly thirty pages on the 24th, but I'm always annoyed that I prefer the parts made by my brother (the Educomix strips) to the parts made by me (everything else). Still, I wouldn't mind a review.

Posted at 2:08PM, Aug. 23, 2009

Aiight, mah niggaz - here is our current list:

Arachnid Goddess
Pancakes
Lacerated View
Omega Justice
Out There
Mystery Bread
Bobby the Fetus
Rated Douk
MAG-ISA
Shaman Quest
The Optimist
Love/Curse
The Hub
Coga Suro
I Would Rather Stay Inside
Good Guy
Counterfeit
Triple Torture
Stickman and Cube
Negligence
Off Hours
Gelotology
John
The Symmetrical Breadpazoid

Posted at 6:08PM, Aug. 23, 2009

hmm, could you review mine at the end of the list? I'd like the plot to develop further first. Which should take 10 more pages which I could do by the time you review all those other comics.

Posted at 10:08AM, Aug. 24, 2009

No problem, Parker.

Arachnid Goddess
Pancakes
Lacerated Veil
Omega Justice
Mystery Bread
Bobby the Fetus
Rated Douk
MAG-ISA
Shaman Quest
The Optimist
Love/Curse
The Hub
Coga Suro
I Would Rather Stay Inside
Good Guy
Counterfeit
Triple Torture
Stickman and Cube
Negligence
Off Hours
Gelotology
John
The Symmetrical Breadpazoid
Out There
Mildly Mundane
Unsung Heroes of Subtlety
Bear vs Zombies

Posted at 3:09PM, Sep. 2, 2009

We only have 8 pages right now, but I mean, if you guys wanna say how were doing SO FAR that would be really cool!

Posted at 5:09PM, Sep. 2, 2009

It's Lacerated VEIL.

Posted at 6:09PM, Sep. 2, 2009

Seeing your review of Off Hours should be quite…enlightening! I'm really glad it made your short list, er, so to speak. B)

Posted at 9:09AM, Sep. 4, 2009

It's Lacerated VEIL.

Ah. That's what I get for copy/pasting off of Harkovast, the furry bastard!

….okay, it's probably my fault. Sorry about that :D

Eric, out of fairness, it would probably be best to turn you down. However, there's a six-seven month wait for a review right now; if you feel you'll have thirty pages up by then, you can just sign up!

Dueeast, the short list is glad to have you.

Seriously, it won't shut the fuck up. "Dueeast this" and "Dueeast that"… ;)

EDIT: Our list has been updated: We call it: Let's see how many sentences we can end with a colon in a row:

Pancakes
Lacerated Veil
Omega Justice
Mystery Bread
Bobby the Fetus
Rated Douk
MAG-ISA
Shaman Quest
The Optimist
Love/Curse
The Hub
Coga Suro
I Would Rather Stay Inside
Good Guy
Counterfeit
Triple Torture
Stickman and Cube
Negligence
Off Hours
Gelotology
John
The Symmetrical Breadpazoid
Out There
Mildly Mundane
Unsung Heroes of Subtlety
Bear vs Zombies
Timeloss
Life and (Maybe) Death of Ed
Smug I Could Do
Louder Than Bombs
Sentinel
Hanged Doll

Posted at 11:09AM, Sep. 7, 2009

You guys didn't put The Door on the list. Unless I'm just blind, which is quite likely lol

Posted at 2:09PM, Sep. 7, 2009

You guys didn't put The Door on the list. Unless I'm just blind, which is quite likely lol

Argh, you're right! Thank you for pointing that out!

…..you can tell we're still kinda new at this, huh?

Alright, I checked both of the threads we have up for dates and all that good stuff, so this list should be accurate:

Pancakes (this week)
Lacerated Veil
Omega Justice
Mystery Bread
Bobby the Fetus
The Door
Negligence
John
Slackman
Rated Douk
MAG-ISA
Shaman Quest
The Optimist
Love/Curse
The Hub
Coga Suro
I Would Rather Stay Inside
Good Guy
Counterfeit
Triple Torture
Stickman and Cube
Off Hours
Gelotology
The Symmetrical Breadpazoid
Out There
Mildly Mundane
Unsung Heroes of Subtlety
Bear vs Zombies
Timeloss
Life and (Maybe) Death of Ed
Smug I Could Do
Louder Than Bombs
Sentinel
Hanged Doll

Whew!

Posted at 2:09PM, Sep. 7, 2009

Oh, bloody hell. That's quite the list. You guys have allot of work ahead for you.

And to think, by the time you're done with this lot, the list will probably be three times longer, >:)

Posted at 8:09AM, Sep. 13, 2009

Nice list…

Always enjoyed webcomic reviews.