Thread "Who wants a free review of their comic?" in forum "Networking & Community Projects*"

Posted at 9:09AM, Sep. 13, 2009

I do not envy you.

Although I am looking forward to reading these reviews.

A little part of me hopes that somebody cries.

Posted at 12:09PM, Sep. 15, 2009

No kidding guys, no kidding… Hark and I have fun doing it though. And we will continue to have fun… all 1,539 times. BECAUSE THAT'S WHAT WE DO.

Here's the updated list:

Lacerated Veil - this week
Omega Justice
Mystery Bread
Bobby the Fetus
The Door
Negligence
John
Slackman
Rated Douk
MAG-ISA
Shaman Quest
The Optimist
Love/Curse
The Hub
Coga Suro
I Would Rather Stay Inside
Good Guy
Counterfeit
Triple Torture
Stickman and Cube
Off Hours
Gelotology
The Symmetrical Breadpazoid
Out There
Mildly Mundane
Unsung Heroes of Subtlety
Bear vs Zombies
Timeloss
Life and (Maybe) Death of Ed
Smug I Could Do
Louder Than Bombs
Sentinel
Hanged Doll
Hainted Holler
ragnadventure
Noise Pollution
Brax the Alien Rocker (our first non-drunk druck review. dizamn)

Posted at 5:09PM, Sep. 25, 2009

Hey, I have a question about joining in. I know you guys say 30 minimum for pages, but I'd like to have a review on Vagabond (which is only 26 pages and a single self contained story). If that doesn't fly, then I'll just wait until Crossbones is long enough.

Still like that "tell it how it is" critique you guys do.

Posted at 2:09AM, Sep. 26, 2009

Thank you, Snake. We couldn't get the DARPA chie-

….I mean thanks, Dr. Luck! I'm glad you're enjoying the reviews :D

I'm sorry, but for sake of fairness, we can't review a comic with less than thirty pages.

Posted at 10:09AM, Sep. 26, 2009

That's cool. I'll come back when Crossbones is long enough.

Posted at 7:10AM, Oct. 3, 2009

Latest list!

Bobby the Fetus (this week)
The Door
Negligence
John
Slackman
Rated Douk
MAG-ISA
Shaman Quest
The Optimist
Love/Curse
The Hub
Coga Suro
I Would Rather Stay Inside
Good Guy
Counterfeit
Triple Torture
Stickman and Cube
Off Hours
Gelotology
The Symmetrical Breadpazoid
Out There
Mildly Mundane
Unsung Heroes of Subtlety
Bear vs Zombies
Timeloss
Life and (Maybe) Death of Ed
Smug I Could Do
Louder Than Bombs
Sentinel
Hanged Doll
Hainted Holler
ragnadventure
Noise Pollution
The Elemental Storm
FIGHT 2
South of Sanity

Posted at 12:10AM, Oct. 19, 2009

If you don't mind reviewing a backgroundless 3-panel, "Splices of Life" would love to be reviewed XD http://www.drunkduck.com/Splices_of_Life/

Posted at 10:10PM, Oct. 21, 2009

Updated list:

Negligence (this week)
John
Slackman
Rated Douk
MAG-ISA
Shaman Quest
The Optimist
Love/Curse
The Hub
Coga Suro
I Would Rather Stay Inside
Good Guy
Counterfeit
Triple Torture
Stickman and Cube
Off Hours
Gelotology
The Symmetrical Breadpazoid
Out There
Mildly Mundane
Unsung Heroes of Subtlety
Bear vs Zombies
Timeloss
Life and (Maybe) Death of Ed
Smug I Could Do
Louder Than Bombs
Sentinel
Hanged Doll
Hainted Holler
ragnadventure
Noise Pollution
Brax the Alien Rocker
The Elemental Storm
FIGHT 2
South of Sanity
Ed Contradictory
Last of the Wilds
Fools and Such
Rectangles
Bruzela Proyect
Splices of Life
Wayout West
Pink Lady

Posted at 11:10PM, Oct. 21, 2009

Hark has already givin me a personal review but a comic version sounds so much fun.

Please sign up "No Talent" ;D

Posted at 8:10AM, Oct. 22, 2009

Woo-ha, page 30 will update on Sunday, so count me in for the review-fest!

btw, how do you guys put those fancy banners in your signatures?

Posted at 4:10AM, Oct. 23, 2009

Hang on!
There has been a thread here all along?

I was running a completely separate thread getting people to sign up on the "look what I did" section!!

Wow, we are like a well oiled machine.
Or possibly two well oiled machines running side by side doing the same job and thus making each other redundant.

(My thread is much better. It is where all the cool people sign up!)

Posted at 9:10AM, Oct. 23, 2009

Finally! I've hit 30 pages full of comedy, mystery, adventure, and at least one savage beating!

http://www.drunkduck.com/Jake_the_Evil_hare

Posted at 6:10AM, Oct. 25, 2009

I'd really love to be reveiwed Hark. I got 54 and counting and you know me I am trying to fix em. (sorry that I failed you w/ a few hadwritten text bits in comics-hint hint, inside joke)

Posted at 4:10PM, Oct. 25, 2009

Why not? If you're still up for it, feel free to Review Mob Ties. It has over 800 pages, so I think I meet the requirements.

Posted at 12:11AM, Nov. 2, 2009

Updated list (jesus christ this thing is getting long!):

Slackman (this week)
Rated Douk
MAG-ISA
Shaman Quest
The Optimist
Love/Curse
The Hub
Coga Suro
I Would Rather Stay Inside
Good Guy
Counterfeit
Triple Torture
Stickman and Cube
Off Hours
Gelotology
The Symmetrical Breadpazoid
Out There
Mildly Mundane
Unsung Heroes of Subtlety
Bear vs Zombies
Timeloss
Life and (Maybe) Death of Ed
Smug I Could Do
Louder Than Bombs
Sentinel
Hanged Doll
Hainted Holler
ragnadventure
Noise Pollution
Brax the Alien Rocker
The Elemental Storm
FIGHT 2
South of Sanity
Ed Contradictory
Last of the Wilds
Fools and Such
Rectangles
Bruzela Proyect
Splices of Life
Wayout West
Pink Lady
No Talent
Jake the Evil Hare
House of Muses
Pwned Randomness
Mob Ties
Anecdote
@$$hole!
Revfitz
Anatta
Agency

Posted at 1:11PM, Nov. 4, 2009

Holy moly, that's a lot of reviews!
At least we aren't in danger of running out of material.

Posted at 8:11AM, Nov. 5, 2009

Holy moly, that's a lot of reviews!
At least we aren't in danger of running out of material.

You have your work cut out for you hark.

Posted at 10:11AM, Nov. 11, 2009

That list has 50 comics it. There are about 52 weeks in a year…good luck.

Posted at 4:11PM, Nov. 11, 2009

Oh I definitely have room for improvement! Go ahead-I'd love to hear your opinion on my comic "Stitches." Keep in mind I'm kind of in a transition-y stage of improvement so the newer pages reflect the comic page's quality more than the older ones. But I can take the harsh stuff so please sign me up!

Posted at 1:11PM, Nov. 13, 2009

I know, Niccea, I know… it's daunting, but at least we'll always be busy!

Also, we removed Pink Lady, as the creator already has another comic on the list. I guess we forgot to include that rule - only one comic per artist can be on the list at a time. …and then the whole thirty comic minimum thing, too.

Here's the current list:

MAG-ISA (this week)
Shaman Quest
The Optimist
Love/Curse
The Hub
Coga Suro
I Would Rather Stay Inside
Good Guy
Counterfeit
Triple Torture
Stickman and Cube
Off Hours
Gelotology
The Symmetrical Breadpazoid
Out There
Mildly Mundane
Unsung Heroes of Subtlety
Bear vs Zombies
Timeloss
Life and (Maybe) Death of Ed
Smug I Could Do
Louder Than Bombs
Sentinel
Hanged Doll
Hainted Holler
ragnadventure
Noise Pollution
Brax the Alien Rocker
The Elemental Storm
FIGHT 2
South of Sanity
Ed Contradictory
Last of the Wilds
Fools and Such
Rectangles
Bruzela Proyect
Splices of Life
Wayout West
No Talent
Jake the Evil Hare
House of Muses
Pwned Randomness
Mob Ties
Anecdote
@$$hole!
Revfitz
Anatta
Agency
Salt the Holly
Hyacinth Duck
Razor Candy
Stitches
Opaque Dreams

Posted at 9:11PM, Nov. 16, 2009

Heck, I'll throw Trolling Around in the mix. I'm feeling wild.

Posted at 11:11PM, Nov. 16, 2009

Alright Disgruntled, you've been added :D

MAG-ISA (this week)
Shaman Quest
The Optimist
Love/Curse
The Hub
Coga Suro
I Would Rather Stay Inside
Good Guy
Counterfeit
Triple Torture
Stickman and Cube
Off Hours
Gelotology
The Symmetrical Breadpazoid
Out There
Mildly Mundane
Unsung Heroes of Subtlety
Bear vs Zombies
Timeloss
Life and (Maybe) Death of Ed
Smug I Could Do
Louder Than Bombs
Sentinel
Hanged Doll
Hainted Holler
ragnadventure
Noise Pollution
Brax the Alien Rocker
The Elemental Storm
FIGHT 2
South of Sanity
Ed Contradictory
Last of the Wilds
Fools and Such
Rectangles
Bruzela Proyect
Splices of Life
Wayout West
No Talent
Jake the Evil Hare
House of Muses
Pwned Randomness
Mob Ties
Anecdote
@$$hole!
Revfitz
Anatta
Agency
Salt the Holly
Hyacinth Duck
Razor Candy
Stitches
Opaque Dreams
Light Within Shadow
Trolling Around

Posted at 3:11AM, Nov. 22, 2009

Can I add Gothenreich Chronicles, pwease

Posted at 4:11PM, Nov. 22, 2009

Yes you can, it would be our pweasure.

Shaman Quest (this week)
The Optimist
Love/Curse
The Hub
Coga Suro
I Would Rather Stay Inside
Good Guy
Counterfeit
Triple Torture
Stickman and Cube
Off Hours
Gelotology
The Symmetrical Breadpazoid
Out There
Mildly Mundane
Unsung Heroes of Subtlety
Bear vs Zombies
Timeloss
Life and (Maybe) Death of Ed
Smug I Could Do
Louder Than Bombs
Sentinel
Hanged Doll
Hainted Holler
ragnadventure
Noise Pollution
Brax the Alien Rocker
The Elemental Storm
FIGHT 2
South of Sanity
Ed Contradictory
Last of the Wilds
Fools and Such
Rectangles
Bruzela Proyect
Splices of Life
Wayout West
No Talent
Jake the Evil Hare
House of Muses
Pwned Randomness
Mob Ties
Anecdote
@$$hole!
Revfitz
Anatta
Agency
Salt the Holly
Hyacinth Duck
Razor Candy
Stitches
Opaque Dreams
Light Within Shadow
Trolling Around
Gothenreich Chronicles

Posted at 1:11AM, Nov. 27, 2009

Hey there,

do you mind reviewing my comics?

I have 2 active comics, so far. You could choose whichever you like.