Thread "Sign up to get your comic reviewed." in forum "Networking & Community Projects*"

Posted at 3:08AM, Aug. 2, 2011

I requested this review some time ago, but I have since changed my comic's home.
If you're still willing to review me, it's here. RPS @ Comic Fury

Posted at 6:08AM, Aug. 2, 2011

That's fine, i had seen that you had moved.

Posted at 9:08PM, Aug. 3, 2011

With the Duke of Solitaire review, are you doing just the pages on Drunk Duck or the full archive at the main site?

Posted at 9:08AM, Aug. 4, 2011

Main site, I think you recommended that before. The review goes live on the 25th of august when the current story finishes. the next review, benus as a boy will be about a week after. Used books review will be shortly after that, depending on the length of the story in between.

Posted at 11:08PM, Aug. 12, 2011

Duke of solitaire 25th August
Venus as a boy 1st september
Used books 3rd sepember, it's an epic review.
Jake the evil hare. 9th september
Lugnor Riders and tales of Lugnor 14th september
RPS Without moonlight

Shaman quest
Soul symphony
Dark sisters
Deadhead zero
Shades
Eat
If I get locked up tonite.
The garden
Ryu's crew
Comfortably numb.

Still trying to clear the backlog at the moment but if you want to sign up, go right on ahead.

Posted at 1:08PM, Aug. 14, 2011

next weekend you'll have my second input :)

Posted at 3:08PM, Aug. 14, 2011

The timing of that will be very handy. thankyou. I will be finishing a bunch of reviews this week.

Posted at 10:08AM, Aug. 15, 2011

I'm willing to put up my comic Nectar of the Gods, I'll most likely react in a shameful way if it gets a bad review, but if i do, it just means i'm acknowledging your critiques and realizing that i need to fix those parts =) just a warning

Posted at 11:08AM, Aug. 15, 2011

It's on the list. I haven't read the comic yet but have glanced over it before, it didn't strike me as being terrible…
Duke of solitaire 25th August
Venus as a boy 1st september
Used books 3rd sepember, it's an epic review.
Jake the evil hare. 9th september
Lugnor Riders and tales of Lugnor 14th september
RPS
Without moonlight     Shaman quest
Soul symphony
Dark sisters
Deadhead zero
Shades
Eat
If I get locked up tonite.
The garden
Ryu's crew
Comfortably numb.
Nectar of the gods.

Posted at 11:08AM, Aug. 15, 2011

Well if you actually like it (which is really only the case with other bartenders), then I'll be extatic =D

Posted at 1:08PM, Aug. 15, 2011

I used to be a bar manager, so it may play a part. One of the reasons there are at least two reviewers on a comic is to balance opinion.

Posted at 4:08PM, Aug. 15, 2011

Genejoke wrote:
I used to be a bar manager, so it may play a part. One of the reasons there are at least two reviewers on a comic is to balance opinion.

if that's the case i apologize ahead of time if i made any mistakes in the bar thing >.< I don't have any REAL experience working in a bar, but i've asked a lot of real bartenders to get information, so it may not be 100% accurate

Posted at 12:08AM, Aug. 16, 2011

A comic that isn't 100% accurate? shocking, whatevers next, stickmen comics…

Posted at 6:08PM, Aug. 18, 2011

Epic?

I'm both excited and terrified. o_0 Eep

Posted at 12:08AM, Aug. 19, 2011

It is a bit different to other reviews, I could have doubled up some of the pages like we have on other reviews, but it works well as it is.

Posted at 5:09AM, Sep. 8, 2011

I'm sorry to say the Jake the evil hare review is going to be delayed, entirely my fault i just wasn't happy with it so I'm starting over. The next one up will be the Lugnor series review then I will post the Jake review about a week after that.
I'm trying to get a better routine together for doing reviews as I have become a bit too disorganised.

Posted at 4:09AM, Sep. 14, 2011

I really like how you guys review stuff. If you want you could review Attack of the Robofemoids even though it's finished.

Posted at 5:09AM, Sep. 14, 2011

We can do that.
Jake the evil hare. NOW LIVE
RPS Aiming for 10th october
Without moonlight
Shaman quest
Soul symphony
Dark sisters
Deadhead zero
Shades
Eat
If I get locked up tonite.
The garden
Ryu's crew
Comfortably numb.
Nectar of the gods.
Attack of the robofemoids

Posted at 12:09AM, Sep. 30, 2011

I tried a review comic, once. Commodity and I ran it, and we had a decent list of things to review, too. But with the site changeover, he quit and yeah. It died.

Anyways, I'm feeling pretty bold, so go ahead and review my comic too. http://www.drunkduck.com/La_Vie_a_la_Mode/

Posted at 2:09AM, Sep. 30, 2011

Damn, you're getting dangerously close to mine. Guess I better put another page up soon….

Posted at 3:09AM, Sep. 30, 2011

Deadhead zero is the next one to start working on as the others are in hand, however I going to finish all of those before starting work on it. I had too many on the go at once and it got on top of me so now I'm streamlining the work flow.
Without moonlight Shaman quest Soul symphony Dark sisters Deadhead zero Shades Eat If I get locked up tonite. The garden Ryu's crew Comfortably numb. Nectar of the gods. Attack of the robofemoids
La vie a la mode
@Nicky P, Added. If you are interested in helping out with reviews you are welcome to, just let me know.

Posted at 6:10AM, Oct. 6, 2011

I'm sure the reviewers have plenty to say about the fluctuating art quality. I don't really have any excuses at this point.

Posted at 11:10PM, Oct. 6, 2011

mikemacdee wrote:
I'm sure the reviewers have plenty to say about the fluctuating art quality. I don't really have any excuses at this point.

Funny you mention that. Your comic was the next one Commodity and I were going to do, before our review comic died. And one of our points was the fluctuating art quality! XD

I'll PQ you a copy of my notes from the review. It's from June, so my comments might not be as valid as you could have changed some things since then.

Posted at 2:10AM, Oct. 7, 2011

Thanks for the heads-up on that. Actually makes me less worried about the comic I'm wanting to do next, which has a regular ol' contemporary setting.
My reply about sums up why the art was so nutty: elbow injuries, lack of readers, need of drawing practice, inventing a better comic (and art style)….

Posted at 2:10AM, Oct. 11, 2011

I'm afraid that the without moonlight review will slip until after the Shaman quest review, purely my fault as I have a house move going on, among other things. The Shaman quest review has visuals done by someone else so isn't being held up by me. Once without moonlight is done souls symphony and dark sisters will follow very quickly.
Shaman quest 28th oct
without moonlight early november
Soul symphony Dark sisters Deadhead zero Shades Eat If I get locked up tonite. The garden Ryu's crew Comfortably numb. Nectar of the gods. Attack of the robofemoids