Advertise with us

Moonlight meanderer

The Offical Mafia 4 Game Thread: Mafia 4, Mafia Harder!

Posted at

lets avoid lynching people on the first day

See, that's what I would say even if my head WASN'T on the chopping block. The only leads we have right now are EXTREMELY flimsy, and killing ANY innocent townie would only help the Mafia along. Now, if we had some REAL clues at this point, that would be different…

Oh, and for the record, it's "he" not "she" (apparently, the facial hair on my avatar is kind of hard to see)

Ozoneocean
Ozoneocean
status:
offline
posts:
199
joined:
01/02/2004
Posted at

I believe that Crocty isn't mafia, but how do we know the police cheif is really the police chief?
When I was mayor the first time, Skool told me she was the paranoid. Much later gullas came and told me that he was the paranoid. And because of certain clues and things during the game I believed that Skool was the real one and Gullas was fake.

I don't doubt the mafia would try tricks like that.

And Hark's blind instance that Blitz MUST be the killer even though we've all shown how his "clue" connects everyone to waff's murder in the same way indicates to me that Hark is either mad, up to his old tricks of playing the crazy man, or he's the actual killer?

-I DON'T think he's the killer BTW.

I'm sorry but that's intolerably rude
And it's rude that you didn't acknowledge what I told you about Claudius not being the killer (TWICE), which is why I said that was moronic reasoning. So I think we're one for one.

Posted at

ya'll think my theory is a stretch well i don't jump from the beginning to suspect then fill the middle with bull. i move from beginning to suspects like a real investigator. so what if my theory has to suspects at least there would be egg on my face if one is innocent

Posted at

I'm gonna change my vote to "no lynch" if that's possible. If "no lynch" gets more votes then the prime suspect I say we skip it for this day.

How's that for a new law, Baron?

Posted at

And if not, our friendly neighborhood pardoner could always go to work.

crocty
crocty
status:
offline
posts:
199
joined:
08/16/2007
Posted at

I believe that Crocty isn't mafia, but how do we know the police cheif is really the police chief?
When I was mayor the first time, Skool told me she was the paranoid. Much later gullas came and told me that he was the paranoid. And because of certain clues and things during the game I believed that Skool was the real one and Gullas was fake.
He told me information that only me and the captain knew.
I have no doubt that who I'm talking to is the captain.

Aghammer
Aghammer
status:
offline
posts:
199
joined:
06/11/2008
Posted at

Well, while I don't think we have any "smoking guns" (heh) with any of the clues if that becomes a new law .. all of the mafia will vote for it every single day :)

I'm gonna change my vote to "no lynch" if that's possible. If "no lynch" gets more votes then the prime suspect I say we skip it for this day.

How's that for a new law, Baron?

Ozoneocean
Ozoneocean
status:
offline
posts:
199
joined:
01/02/2004
Posted at

Well in that case Crocty… with so many clues pointing to PP and you say he's 100% NOT the killer, I have no one to vote for.

My vote stands: I vote to lynch myself.
Barron has it, I PQed him ages ago.

—-
And now I'm going to bed, G'night, it's 2 am here. -_-

Posted at

And it's rude that you didn't acknowledge what I told you about Claudius not being the killer (TWICE), which is why I said that was moronic reasoning. So I think we're one for one.
In what fantasy land do you live in? I did acknowledge what you said. We wrote our responses at the same time so I didn't see what you said until after I was done posting my hypothesis. I then went on to edit my post to respond to yours.

My second post then states: Even if Yorick was not killed by Claudius…

In all seriousness, I DEMAND an apology from you.

Well, while I don't think we have any "smoking guns" (heh) with any of the clues if that becomes a new law .. all of the mafia will vote for it every single day :)
Hmm… you're right about that. Although I guess if someone's constantly pushing the no lynch button, he'll be incriminating himself. Even today the mafia manipulates the votes by voting for someone who's innocent.

Posted at

Actually, having just looked back to the start of the game…

The mayor can not call off a lynch, there will be a lynch everyday

…so even if it's The People voting against it, a "no lynch" option would be violating the rules. It looks like my only hope now is some major mercy from the pardoner.

Ozoneocean
Ozoneocean
status:
offline
posts:
199
joined:
01/02/2004
Posted at

In all seriousness, I DEMAND an apology from you.
Fantasy land? You posted AFTER me, I didn't see any edit that solved things, that so called edit just went one with the previous stuff.
I demand you stop being a dick.

Good night

Posted at

what if blitz is someone we need. the past tells us that the first day lynching always get someone we need. and those who do not learn from history are doomed to repeat it

Posted at

In all seriousness, I DEMAND an apology from you.
Fantasy land? You posted AFTER me, I didn't see any edit that solved things, that so called edit just went one with the previous stuff.
I demand you stop being a dick.

Good night

What are you talking about? I did edit my post. Look at the time of both posts. They're from the same minute. Your post wasn't there when I started writing mine. I couldn't take your post into consideration because it wasn't there to be read as I made it.

I'm not gonna let this go away. I'm actually angry at you.
what if blitz is someone we need. the past tells us that the first day lynching always get someone we need. and those who do not learn from history are doomed to repeat it
It's a certain risk indeed. However, if he's someone important, I'm sure Crocty would try to protect him. Crocty did go out in trying to figure out all the important roles so he could co-ordinate their efforts.

Posted at

Well it's obvious that we're pushing each other buttons at the moment. I apologize for my outburst as it's not in the spirit of the game. Oz and I are talking now through PQ's so we won't bother you with this.

crocty
crocty
status:
offline
posts:
199
joined:
08/16/2007
Posted at

well, I'm not the only one who's realised this:
This day has gone for three days.
We have a time bender on the mafia's side, and the votes for Blitz would mean that he would die at the end of the day.

Time bender…Extra day…Blitz due for lynching…

Uhhh…

Posted at

well, I'm not the only one who's realised this:
This day has gone for three days.
We have a time bender on the mafia's side, and the votes for Blitz would mean that he would die at the end of the day.

Time bender…Extra day…Blitz due for lynching…

Uhhh…
hahahahahahaha!

now you get it?

crocty
crocty
status:
offline
posts:
199
joined:
08/16/2007
Posted at

Sorry, I'm not as informed about the time bender.
Would you like to fill me in?

That was a seriously smug response. I'm not just saying this because I hate smug people, but it's almost like you're saying that because you want to outright state you knew that before.

Like a "I'm smarter than you because I already knew this".

Now, how would you know this already~?

Posted at

EDIT: …IS there a time bender? I see no mention of one at the start of the thread, but there is much I don't underdstand.

Oh well, I gave up all hope of living a while ago anyway. Go ahead, feel free lynch me and feel stupid afterward.

Posted at

Sorry, I'm not as informed about the time bender.
Would you like to fill me in?
the mafia can control time

crocty
crocty
status:
offline
posts:
199
joined:
08/16/2007
Posted at

It's definitely not looking good for you now…
(Directed at Blitz)

Sorry, I'm not as informed about the time bender.
Would you like to fill me in?
the mafia can control time
They can end days early from what we saw.
You have proof that they can make days longer?

Posted at

Has it been three days?

I thought we "gained" and extra day because the night shift started early. I think that Baron intends to let each day/night cycle last approximately 24 hours. Since the mafia started the first night early it's caused a bleeding effect where the next day is longer to balance it. Either that or Baron's really shitty with a clock.

Posted at

Really? …DANG IT!!! Even I'D vote for me now!

Oh well, I gave up all hope of living a while ago anyway. Go ahead, feel free lynch me and feel stupid afterward.
i will defend you blitz pro bono

crocty
crocty
status:
offline
posts:
199
joined:
08/16/2007
Posted at

Someone who knows more about the Hiro than the rest of us, protecting someone who the majority believe to be mafia?

Hmmm~

Niccea
Niccea
status:
offline
posts:
199
joined:
08/10/2007
Posted at

-.- That is why I have proposed that "Time Bender" should be added to the ranks of roles to never be repeated.

And LoS is right about us invoking Vak's Law of Mafia Probability.

Advertise with us

Moonlight meanderer

DDComics is community owned.

The following patrons help keep the lights on. You can support DDComics on Patreon.